Jun 09 2008
Phonelocator.mobi vs sniffu.com
I read an interesting article in the Sunday Times, Beware the traitor in your pocket, which mentioned a couple of services that at first glance appeared to be phonelocator.mobi competitors. The more interesting of the two is sniffu.com. Unlike phonelocator.mobi, which uses GPS to locate the mobile phone, sniffu.com uses a positioning information provided by the mobile operator. The network operator can calculate the approximate location of the phone because it it knows which base stations it is in contact with.
This kind of system works best in metropolitan areas where there are many base stations in close proximity. Even in London however, the system does not appear to be particularly accurate.
I tried out sniffu.com yesterday on a T-mobile handset , and it produced this map:
The actual location of the phone was here, as revealed by phonelocator:
As you can see from the two maps. The phonelocator one is much more detailed. If you compare where the river is on both maps you can see that the phone is actually located in the outer extremities of the circle on the sniffu.com map.
I’ll now attempt to compare the features of the two products:
| phonelocator | sniffu.com | |
| Accuacy | GPS accuracy (~1-15 meters) | When tested in a metropolitan stetting on T-mobile, the user was shown as being somewhere in a circle that is ~1200m in diameter. |
| Cost | Free, but sends a small amount of data that the network operator may charge for. | Successful sniffs incur a 50p charge. |
| Remote activation | Not currently available. | Can be setup so that your friends can request your position. |
| Client software install. | Required. | Not required. |
| Handset compatibility | Nokia Series 60 with GPS only. | All |
| Trail | Trails can be saved. | Trails can’t be saved. |
| Indoor use | GPS is less likely to work indoors. | Performance the same indoors and outdoors. |
| Battery life | GPS usage will cause extra drain on phone battery. | Battery life unaffected. |
| Facebook integration | Not yet | Yes |





